Public Enemies Review
Public Enemies
Directed by: Michael Mann
Produced by: Michael Mann and Kevin Misher
Screenplay by: Ronan Bennett, Ann Biderman and Michael Mann
Book by: Bryan Burrough
Starring: Johnny Depp, Christian Bale, Marion Cotillard
Cinematography by: Dante Spinotti
Distributed by: Universal Pictures
Running Time: 140 min (2 hr 20 mins)
Budget: $100 Million
Cinematography: I hated it. I may be nit picking, but I really disliked the cinematography. I realize what they were trying to do, however I believe they could have accomplished a similar feel without the film looking so disgusting and cheap. it feels like the film cost 10 million rather than $100 million.
I really didn’t think the cheap digital video doc style fit with this film. It kept pulling me out. The digital look makes me think of reality tv, poorly produced reality tv at that. I don’t normally have a problem with the doc handheld style of filmmaking, however I didn’t think it fit with the film, or used effectively. It felt like they were making the film for speed rather than storytelling.
I felt the handheld was sloppy and inconsistent, and at times they just stopped and made it more of a tradition drama. I think the style worked much better in Rachel Getting Married, than it did for Public Enemies.
Directing: biggest complaint was that I really didn’t like how many close ups were shot. Sometimes I didn’t know where any of the characters were. Very confusing, when it could have been more fluid, again, like Rachel Getting Married or The Wrestler.
Sound design: some people really dug it, but I felt it was again very inconsistent. I did enjoy it when the gunshots were muffled, however I felt the dialogue scenes to be distracting with volume levels going up and down. It may have been a theater problem though.
Script: I thought this was one of the weakest points. The film felt more like a list of historical facts, with loose exposition put in-between, added with a sloppy love story. I didn’t care for a lot of the characters, and I had no reason to. Nothing really happens in this film thats engaging other than a few gun fights. The actors had almost nothing to work with, no one was developed in any meaningful way and a lot could have been cut out from this film.
Acting: I thought the acting was done well with what the actors had to work with, though I did had a minor problem with Christian Bale’s accent at times.
Overall, I didn’t like this film very much, with the script problems, and cinematography putting below enjoyable. It does have some decent action scenes, but because of the way they are shot I really think it takes away from what could have been good, or great action scenes.
4.5/10
Jul 10, 2009 @ 3:42 am